Why are Human Photo Editors Better than AI?

Posted by

Why are Human Photo Editors Better than AI

In the vast digital landscape, where attention spans are shorter than ever (50 milliseconds only), first impressions matter the most. The stakes are high, so you need to get website imagery right.

While clicking the perfect image is essential, the importance of editing cannot be overstated. However, the process of image editing has undergone a significant transformation due to the rapid advancements in AI technology. AI-powered tools have emerged, promising to revolutionize the way we enhance, retouch, and manipulate images. But does this mean machines can outperform the human eye? 

Not quite! Here’s why:

Security Threats

Do you know how much personal information you’re giving away when you upload your images to AI photo editors? This is not to scare you; AI might let you edit the photos in the blink of an eye, but you should be cautious while using it.

Uploading your photos to an AI photo editor means granting the software access to your private data, encompassing images, location details, and additional metadata. The entity who owns that AI tool can utilize this information for various objectives, like refining their algorithms or even selling the data to external parties. Consequently, this action poses a potential threat to your privacy and that of others whose pictures might be encompassed within your image collection as these images can be manipulated and used in misleading ways.

This issue gets eliminated while working with human editors. You only share the specific images you want to be edited without providing additional metadata or personal information. Unlike AI photo editors, humans do not have direct access to your location details or other sensitive data associated with the images. Additionally, human editors are bound by professional ethics and confidentiality agreements, reducing the risk of data misuse or unauthorized sharing.

Ethical & Legal Risks

AI-based image editors pose significant ethical and legal challenges, from harmful bias and copyright concerns to potential misuse and misleading content, with serious ramifications. 

One of the core issues lies in the training data used for these AI algorithms, often sourced from personal pictures uploaded on social media. This raises concerns about privacy violations, as these images can be used for creating deep fakes or exploited in scams. The AI-generated images may also reflect existing biases present in the internet’s vast information pool, leading to unfair, inaccurate, and discriminatory results, including racial or gender discrimination. Another critical aspect is the ownership and copyright of the images produced by these editors, as they are generated without human intervention. This lack of clarity on ownership could result in legal disputes surrounding the usage and distribution of such images.

Lack of Accountability

The concerning reality surrounding AI-based photo editing software is the lack of accountability, where nobody seems to take responsibility for the blunders and misinformation that arise from its misuse. 

With the ease of manipulating images using advanced AI algorithms, it becomes increasingly challenging to identify the originators of fake or manipulated content. This anonymity allows malicious actors to disseminate false information without repercussions, leading to potential harm, social unrest, and erosion of trust in media and visual content. 

Cost Factor

When considering the cost factor in photo editing, it’s crucial to look beyond the price tag. Adobe Photoshop for example is a full-featured photo editing and design app that has added several AI-powered features in recent years, such as the ability to remove background noise, upscale images, and generate realistic textures. It is available as a monthly subscription for $19.99/month or as part of an annual plan for $239.88/year. But is it more cost-effective than professional editors? Well, no. AI photo editing tools may appear less expensive upfront, but the value delivered by a human photo editing service provider often surpasses AI.  

Human editors, with their ability to understand context, infuse creativity, and add a personal touch, deliver superior results that justify the cost. Investing in human photo editing services can be particularly beneficial for professional photography, where quality and attention to detail are essential.

Consider a high-end fashion shoot. The cost of human editing might be higher, but the quality of the results – the enhanced textures, the attention to color grading, the creative retouching – can significantly elevate the final images, making them more impactful. It is why despite the popularity of AI apps like Lensa AI, which recorded over 5.8 million downloads worldwide as of December 2022, many professionals still prefer the quality of human editing. 

Contextual Understanding

Context is paramount in photo editing. Human photo editors excel in this area, as they can interpret the narrative, emotion, and intent behind an image. They can enhance a photo while preserving its original message, an invaluable skill in professional photo editing services.

AI, while technologically advanced, lacks this contextual understanding. It can analyze an image based on algorithms but struggles to comprehend the emotion or story behind it. This limitation can lead to edits that may distort the original intent of the photo.

Consider a sunset photo that needs subtle enhancement. An editor, understanding the context, would know how to amplify the natural beauty without making it look artificial. An AI might apply a generic filter, potentially resulting in an over-saturated, unnatural image.

Creativity & Customization

Creativity and customization are not just add-ons in photo editing. They are essential. It is where the skills of human editors outshine AI. Human editors can infuse their work with a unique creative flair. They can look at a photo and see what’s present and what could be.

They can add elements, adjust colors, or manipulate light and shadow to transform a simple image into a work of art. Moreover, they can tailor their edits to align with the specific purpose of each photo, ensuring that the final result looks good and serves its intended function.

AI, for all its efficiency, struggles in this area. It can perform tasks and apply filters, but AI cannot truly innovate or customize. It follows preset algorithms and produces results that, while technically correct, often lack the creative spark that makes a photo stand out.

For instance, consider a portrait that needs to be edited for a fashion magazine. An editor could adjust the lighting, tweak the colors, and add elements to give the photo a unique, high-fashion feel. An AI, on the other hand, would apply preset adjustments, resulting in a technically correct but potentially uninspiring image.

Quality Over Speed

When it comes to photo editing, quality often trumps speed. AI-based tools, with their quick processing times, can be enticing. However, the quality of work a professional photo editing service provider produces often surpasses AI. 

Editors can spot and correct errors that AI might overlook, ensuring a flawless final product. Even though human editing might take longer, the superior results justify the wait. In professional photography, where every detail matters, the meticulous touch of a human editor can make a significant difference, outweighing the speed benefits of AI.

Wrapping Up

While AI has revolutionized the field of photo editing, it cannot supplant the expertise, creativity, and contextual understanding that photo editors offer. The balance between human and AI photo editing currently leans towards the former, especially when quality, creativity, and the human touch are supreme. Investing in a professional human photo editing service provider can make a significant difference for those seeking superior results in their photo editing needs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *